If You’re Addicted to Being Nice, Read On

Many of you asked me how I gave up being a nice-aholic, which I talked about in a previous blog titled Is Your Kindness Killing You? If you’ve been following my writing, then you know I had a bad habit of not saying what I really thought in some important relationships and then ended up suffering the consequences. I had the habit of getting into conflicts or disappointments with people and then complaining to my friends or coach about it, while not saying what I really wanted to the source of my frustration – all of which lead me to being increasingly unhappy about the whole situation! I used to have a weird experience of feeling right or justified about complaining. But this approach really took me far away from dealing with the real situation in front of me.

That’s until I learned what I could do about it. There were discrete action steps my coach taught me that enabled me to just take a deep breath, get clear about what I wanted and tell the truth in a clear, honest way. Funny enough, I became able to talk to someone with whom I was having a conflict without creating more problems.  I avoided conflict externally, but I also suffered from internal conflict – and learning how to be fully expressed changed all that.

The concept of “balancing grace and wisdom,” as my coach put it, was a new concept to me. Growing up in my family, there were only two choices: blow up or stuff it  – neither of which was a healthy choice any more.

What do we mean by “grace”? We mean communicating in a way to others so that they really want to listen and hear what you have to say. For me, it meant doing the mental, physical and emotional preparation for the conversation so that I was calm and cool and could say what I was experiencing without blaming the other person or exaggerating about what had happened. It also meant being open to the fact that I may not understand everything about the other person’s perspective and that I must ask for their perspective, and then listen to what they said. My coach taught me to repeat back what I was hearing to confirm that I understood and to give them a feeling of being heard and understood. This actually works great!

What we mean by “wisdom” is that I had to say the whole truth of what I thought. This was really hard for me, because either I was afraid of hurting someone or afraid they would be upset with me. I was used to pussy-footing around things. So, saying it all straight to their face took some practice. I still think through difficult conversations before I have them – to make sure they go well and I say everything I need to say. Turns out, it’s a lot easier when the conversation is framed positively, set-up in advance and I am under the assumption I am going to learn something.

Here are the basic steps I follow when designing any difficult conversation:

  1. Get permission. This is part of grace. You have to ask the person if it’s a good time and give them the freedom to choose if and when they have the talk with you. Already this sets them up to want to talk or at least be open. Or if they’re not, you won’t speak yet and you’ll be protected from another blow up!
  2. Explain the situation/context and your goal. This is also part of grace, setting up why you want to have the conversation and what you hope to achieve by having the talk. If you don’t have something positive to say here, you aren’t ready.
  3. Apologize for your role. Another way to truly put your listener at ease is to own your part in the conflict upfront. It’s disarming and helps make the other person feel like you aren’t simply pointing fingers.
  4. Describe your concerns. Here is where the wisdom part kicks in! When you start with grace the other person wants to listen to your perspective. It’s even okay if you have to read from notes. Use phrases like: “This is what it seemed like to me” or “in my experience,” or even “I could be wrong, but what I remember you saying was X.”
  5. Ask for their perspective. And listen. Here grace comes back in again. Maybe you are misremembering or you don’t understand why they did what they did. Here is where you can just directly ask: “How do you remember it?” or “What am I not understanding” or even “What do you think happened and why?”
  6. Decide on promises for the future. Here is where wisdom comes back in. A lot of people get so relieved simply to have said what’s on their mind that they forget the power of structure and accountability. The people in the conversation have to ask themselves “how are we going to prevent this from happening again?” and then agree to certain commitments going forward.

It’s simple, but not always that easy. It takes practice and believe me, it does work. If you know what’s in your way of fabulous relationships with certain people, learning this skill will be invaluable.

16 thoughts on “If You’re Addicted to Being Nice, Read On

  1. Dear Potatoheads,

    Thank you for making such great content, I haven’t found anything like yours elsewhere. I’ll keep on coming back.
    Thank you for not doing what everybody else is doing, your authenticity is on point.


    1. Excellent article!! Sharing with my daughter as she struggles with this, and it very well written!

  2. Nice article. But this approach must be applied to the difficult conversations only and one must know which conversation is difficult. Otherwise there is a risk of silence from the other side. One should refrain from taking every conversation as ‘difficult’ …:)

    1. This article spoke so clearly to me…..I have spent my life avoiding conflict/backing down/apologizing……..I learned a
      painful lesson, and that is when you speak up you also have to be prepared to walk away as that may be the unintended
      consequence………..yes it’s painful/but in the long run it’s honest and liberating.

  3. I think this article is great. One concern I would have is for people who find themselves caught in these situations and how to handle them immediately. Yes planning in advance is great but if you have to revisit every conversation that poses certain challenges too. Being able to collect your thoughts in the moment and have a format to do that would be great. Any thoughts on that?

    1. Personally for me, it’s like I said to Kyrie below. I agree that saying the right thing in the moment is so challenging. In certain situations if it’s worth it, I feel like once you gather your thoughts, you can come back and say to the person, ‘Hey, I didn’t feel too great about that interaction, can we have a talk and revisit it?’

  4. This may work most of the time. But, it doesn’t work if the other person believes that they are never wrong and anything they do is always right. I work with someone who explodes at even the mere thought that she does something someone doesn’t like. A simple “it’s my fault” conversation turns very bad and then she has to “punish” the one who called her on it.

    1. Yes. This works with two rational people. But dealing with narcissists presents a whole seperate set of challenges

  5. Great stuff girl, it reminds me of “Crucial Conversations”. It also makes me think I should make myself a flashcard and put these bullets in my wallet or save to my phone for reference. That’s always the trouble, isn’t it? Putting it in to practice and remembering to take a step back to breath before reacting. Will be subscribing to your newsletter now. Thanks again.

    1. So happy to have you as a new subscriber Kyrie! I agree, saying the right thing in the moment is so challenging. In certain situations if it’s worth it, I feel like once you gather your thoughts, you can come back and say to the person, ‘Hey, I didn’t feel too great about that interaction, can we revisit it?’

  6. Like many others, I spent a lot of years avoiding conflict, backing down and apologizing. At one point I learned a
    painful lesson and that is when you speak up you have to be prepared to walk away……..yes it may be painful but in the long run
    it is honest and liberating.

    1. Thanks for sharing Elaine. That’s so true, you have to be ready to know the other person might not be rational or receptive. And in that instance, I can see how just letting it go is a good route.

What did you think?We want to hear from you!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *