Café Cluny is a definite favorite of ours here at The New Potato. Another masterpiece started by New York restaurateur Keith McNally, it’s an always-dependable neighborhood mainstay where the servers wear St. James boat necks and the front room is just as cozy as the back. They happen to serve one of our favorite burgers in New York (get it with gruyere), as well as a steak frites that kills it every time. When in doubt on sides, do the mushrooms – they’re amazing. Make a Reservation.